Online Bike Coach

Where Cyclists and Triathletes get Faster/Stronger/Leaner/Sooner

Vo2 at Threshold

Vo2 at Threshold – Affirming Outdoor Power at Threshold

Richard Wharton Vo2 at Threshold Online Bike Coach
Vo2 at Threshold can reveal a lot about how cardio-vascular fitness and status. The closer that number is to your Vo2Max, the better.

In my last blog post, I mentioned that for my best 10-minute effort while climbing a trail on a mountain bike, my Vo2 at Threshold read as roughly 55ml/kg/min. I also believed that my Vo2Max was roughly 62ml/kg/min. I was curious to see if these values were valid, so I went back indoors. At my home studio, I performed five weekly 20-minute efforts, specifically to determine whether those two values, Vo2 at Threshold, and Vo2Max, were accurate.

 

Percentage of Vo2Max When Cycling at Threshold Intensity

Different Metabolic Thresholds at a Percentage of Max Wattage
I’ve followed Jem Arnold for about a decade now, as he’s been involved in studying SmO2 for cyclists, as well as a lot of other things. This chart he presents, from a lecture, shows wide variation in ‘Thresholds’, where the body begins to migrate from mostly aerobic energy to anaerobic energy. This post is about Vo2 as a % of Max at Threshold.

There’s a lot of new information coming out about the determination of Training Zones. Essentially, each method of measurement tends to come up with its’ own value, and training zones are then based on those values. Let’s face it – Vo2 at Threshold is expensive to acquire, since it requires a Vo2Master, a Polar H10 chest strap, a Moxy, a Power Meter, and probably a Lactate Tester, which is a product I have owned in the past, but do not own at this time. Instead, I use the Moxy and other readings from the Vo2Master and my Polar H10 chest strap, to determine the most accurate Threshold value for myself.

By looking at ALL of the values, however, I could then apply each of them when training. If the goal is to raise Vo2Max to its’ highest time-limited potential, and to raise % of Vo2Max at Threshold, then having those other metric markers can help me take a more holistic approach to every ride.

The Workout

For these five tests (and probably counting), I used my standard indoor training software, PerfPro Studio. My warmup consisted of a 27-minute protocol that I’ve honed using Moxy muscle oxygen sensors. I did roughly four Vo2master O2 calibrations for each workout, but I only recorded the 20-minute effort on the Vo2Master app. The Vo2Master is best used in a consistent atmosphere, so I used a local 8000 btu air conditioner in my small room, to help keep humidity and temperature under control.

PerfPro Studio Vo2 at Threshold Workout
There’s literally no better piece of software in the cycling fitness world than PerfPro Fitness. The amount of information I can read, along with the myriad ways I can build workouts, remains unmatched.

Here are the results:

Date20Min Vo2 Average20Min Power Average20Min HR Average20Min RR Average20Min DFAA1 Average20Min SmO2 Average20Min EqO2 AverageBest 30-sec Vo2maxVo2 as a % of Max
6-Oct53.5271163350.56.822.262.685%
13-Oct55.1287172390.41524.560.691%
20-Oct57.5281170420.42024.565.288%
27-Oct56.9273172430.4310.225.363.290%
3-Nov56.9273172430.410.225.363.290%
AVERAGE55.98277169.840.40.42612.4424.3662.489%
HIGH57.5287172430.52025.363.291%
LOW53.5271163350.46.822.260.685%
RANGE416980.113.23.12.65%

What the Chart Says

There’s more information on this chart than just Vo2 values, but here’s the summary…

  • My 20-minute average Vo2 over 5 efforts was 56ml/kg/min. This is comparable to the 55ml/kg/min that was observed in the mountain bike climb from the previous, outdoor, post.
  • The highest 30-second Vo2 value over the same 5 efforts, which I’ll call Vo2Max, was 63ml/kg/min. Again – I’ve seen this ‘Vo2Max’ value enough to believe it is accurate. Incidentally, my Garmin 1040 and Garmin Connect continue to show my Vo2Max, per calculation only, at 59-60ml/kg/min, which I believe tracks pretty well, even though it is not using metabolic values, and instead uses calculations.
  • When you take the 20-minute Vo2 at Threshold, and divide it by the 30-second Vo2Max, well, my Vo2 at Threshold occurs at about 89% of my Vo2Max.

Notice that I have not mentioned power, or watts. I’ll explain why…

Vo2 at Threshold is a PHYSIOLOGICAL PHENOMENA

For 27 of my 31 years as a Professional Cycling Coach, pursuing watts at Threshold, watts at Vo2Max, and watts per kilogram per minute, has been a stated priority. However, Physics is immutable, while physiology is incredibly mutable.

For the same amount of physiological effort on the outdoor effort in the previous post, I averaged maybe 235 watts over 10 minutes, and 207 watts over 20 minutes. For these five indoor tests, I averaged about 277 watts over 20 minutes. The delta is too great to ignore.

On that same ride, I averaged 165 beats per minute for the climb, while on these five indoor rides, the average heart rate was 170 beats. Temperature, convection, and evaporation are important considerations for heart rate intensities.

For my climb outdoors, which was not 20 minutes, the average DFAA-1 on AlphaHRV was about a 0.4. For the 5 indoor efforts, it was 0.43. I am becoming more and more convinced that there is something ‘there’ there when it comes to DFAA-1 and Threshold.

Finally, the SMO2 value for my climb was about 25%, while the SMO2 average for the 5 indoor 20-minute efforts was 12.4%. I’m convinced that this is because of micro-recoveries on a mountain bike trail, vs. the consistent resistance of a 2% slope indoors.

I think I want to optimize my physiological markers going forward, and those of my clients, and let the watts take care of themselves from now on. Chasing watts as a primary metric, especially on a mountain bike, can leave a rider disillusioned and frustrated.

Conclusion

Vo2 at Threshold is a great way to assess your current fitness, but it requires expensive apparatus. I still don’t own all of the kit I could possibly wear that would help with this assessment. Knowing that my Vo2 at Threshold, is roughly 89% of my Vo2Max, does reassure me that my fitness, at least in August of 2024, and again in October of 2024, is pretty close to my genetic potential.

The next step, one I won’t attempt until the Spring of 2025, will be to try and grow that Vo2Max up to a 65, 66, or even 68ml/kg/min. This will be INCREDIBLY difficult to achieve as a 55-year old male, but I’d like to try. The next step would be to see if I can HOLD my Vo2 at Threshold near 90% as that Vo2Max rises. This is going to require losing another 2 kilograms of mass, maybe 3. That MAY affect my power output and fatigue levels, so I have to temper action with wisdom on this as we go into the 2025 PreSeason.

Winter is approaching quickly, and the cooler temps mean that I won’t be able to use the Vo2Master outdoors nearly as much. When the snow finally leaves the trails unrideable, I’ll be hyper focused on my indoor efforts in my VQ Velocity until Spring. But until then, I’ll be riding outside on the mountain bike on my beloved Peavine, trying to keep my singletrack skills and dreams alive until April 2025, when I can get back out there again.

I’ll post some follow up blogs about the other metrics featured in the chart above, but I need to consult with some PhD’s that are wiser than I am on these parameters. I also have to thank my client, Ken O’Brien, a retired Bell Labs professional, on his coding assistance for a new project that I’ll reveal next.

Thanks for reading, and ENJOY THE RIDE!

 
 

Vo2Master Vo2Max Value Affirms Garmin Vo2Max Estimator

Vo2Master’s Vo2Max Value Was 98% Consistent with Garmin

Richard Wharton Vo2Master OBC Headquarters
THE THINGS I DO FOR SCIENCE!

In May of this year, I wrote a post about the Garmin Vo2Max Calculator. In July, I was able to test my Vo2Max at OBC Headquarters, to compare values. I performed a Graded Exercise Test, using the Vo2Master app. This app, on a cell phone, trapped data from multiple sources. The Vo2Master’s Vo2Max value showed a 1-point difference from the calculation to the actual results.

Let’s take a look at what I learned about myself.

Remember – Vo2 is translated into: ‘Volume of Oxygen Consumed’. It’s the rate at which Oxygen is absorbed by the body for use in muscle contraction and life-sustaining activities. The Greeks believed that breath was life… and they were right.

The Vo2Master Provides a TON of information!

Vo2Master App Metrics
This is just one page of data fields that I can use on the Vo2Master app. You can also run these fields as graphs. All of the data is stored in a detailed .csv file that can be downloaded and shared for analysis.

Since it launched over 5 years ago, the Vo2Master app continues to improve. Just about any sports fitness product that has Bluetooth transmission can now be recorded. These myriad data points can also be displayed, in numeric or graphical format. My only complaint about this has been the inability to display and record this information on a larger screen, like that found in a laboratory or on a regular PC. But that’s a side project that I’m actually working on via (fitnesshrv.com). The app can also be simulcast from a phone or tablet to a large screen with 3rd party apps or with Apple TV.

For this test, I recorded the following external data points:

  • Load Generator (Ergometer)
  • Power (crank)
  • Heart Rate (chest strap)
  • Heart Rate Variability (HRV)
  • Cadence (crank)
  • SmO2 (Moxy)

These data points allow me to transfer the information learned in from the Vo2Master, over to my body and bike when I’m cycling outdoors.

For the ‘Native’ Vo2Master data, I recorded:

  • Respiratory Frequency
  • Tidal Volume
  • Ventilatory Exhalation in Liters per Minute
  • Expired Oxygen

ALL of this information was recorded on a single .csv file, and a summary report was delivered after the test ended.

Any information that was able to be transmitted via Ant+ signal, was also recorded on my Garmin Head Unit.

Vo2Max Test Parameters

I can build just about any test protocol I wish to construct, but the most common Graded Exercise Tests for Vo2Max are built like this:

  • A decent warmup that includes instrument and ergometer calibration to ensure accuracy.
  • 2-4 minute stages at preset wattage loads.
  • A 25 to 30-watt jump (“step”) at the end of each stage.
Vo2Master Graded Exercise Test App Protocol
The Vo2Master app can perform Graded Exercise Tests, ‘5-1-5’ type tests, and even training intervals. Variations within each set are based on time and intensity.

For this test, I had already warmed up, so I just chose a 5-minute warmup, 3-minute stages, and a 30-watt jump in each step.

The Test

Vo2Master Graded Exercise Test
The area in grey is the exercise load. Purple is the power coming off of my power meter on my bike. Red is my traditional heart rate. Blue is the Vo2 data coming from the Vo2Master.

The test was performed on July 14th of 2024. The previous week, Garmin Connect had my Vo2Max calculated at 57ml/kg/min. The Primary goal was to determine the accuracy of this number. The secondary goal was to determine Ventilatory Threshold #1 (VT1) and Ventilatory Threshold #2 (VT2) to see if those wattage, heart rate, and other physiological results, were in-line with the Calculations made by Garmin Connect.

*** Remember – this is just ONE individual performing ONE Graded Exercise Test. There’s nothing linear or broad. I’ll add to this information over time, but it’s just a snapshot of my fitness, compared to a mathematical algorithm by a fitness company.

I began the test at 100 watts of resistance, which was then raised by 30 watts every 3 minutes. I ended the test at roughly 300 watts of ergometer load, when I was exhausted, and my Max Heart Rate was at a value I hadn’t seen in about 6 months.

A Few Problems with the Data

When you look at the graphs I’m providing, you’ll see that there are two problems with the data, neither of which is enough to discount the information in it, but it IS important to understand the results.

Vo2master test anomalies
I’ll perform this test again some time, using an axle or spider based power meter. I may also acquire the ‘other half’ of the power meter (the left leg – this is a rare, right-leg-only pm), and show why 2-legged pm’s are so much better.

First – there’s a glaring delta between the Ergometer Load and the Power generated. Those two values should be roughly 1:1 (Power should be roughly equal to the resistance provided, per Newton’s Third Law). The Power lagged behind the Ergometer load the entire ride, even after calibrating both devices. I believe the data from the power meter is accurate, however, and it’s the information I would use outdoors or in training. So, while it’s not in line with load, it does still provide valid data.

Second – the power line itself is variable. I blame this on the fact that I use a one-legged power meter indoors, and the data packets can ‘speed up’ or ‘fall behind’ at certain cadences. I’m fully aware of the shortcomings of one-legged powermeters, which is why, when I ride outdoors, I truly prefer axle-based powermeters, and more specifically, ‘two-legged’ power meters that trap the torque on both cranks, and use the information to compute a more accurate and thorough set of data.

For this test, the average for each step was fine, but in the future, I will make two specific changes. I’m going to purchase a more modern trainer, and I’ll purchase the ‘other leg’ of my power meter, so I can get the more accurate information for my indoor-only bike.

Vo2Max Results

The most important question I wanted to know was what the Vo2Master would show my Vo2Max to be, and what that value was in relation to the calculated estimation of Vo2Max from Garmin Connect.

Here are the results:

Vo2master Vo2max Graded Exercise Test Report Results
This is the first page of the Graded Exercise Test Report from Vo2Master. I basically blew a 56 Vo2, which lines up with the calculation that my Garmin Connect has made, at 57 just a week before.

The Vo2Master trapped my Vo2Max at 55.8 milliliters of oxygen consumed per kilogram of body weight per minute of exertion.

Garmin Connect had recorded a 57 about a week earlier. That’s 98% consistent.

I’ll Take it.

Other Fitness Data Points

If you know anything about me, you know I’m a nerd for Data. The goal for me as a Coach, however, is to help ‘distill’ this information in to practical knowledge. That’s why I focus on lower-cost alternatives and Garmin Connect, to set fitness levels, training zones, and fitness programs. Progression does require frequent re-assessment, however, which is why I like using the Vo2Master. It provides the ultimate, scientifically validated information that we can then use to reset these zones with more accuracy.

Vo2master Heart Rate Vs Wattage Graph with VT1 and VT2
The linear plot between heart rate and wattage is nice, but it’s even better when you plot VT1 and VT2 against the other two metrics. This gives you the knowledge to understand just how ‘hard’ you can ride before physiological and metabolic changes in energy consumption start to occur.

Ventilatory Threshold 1 (VT1)

Ventilatory Threshold 1 (VT1) is a point in time where the Respiratory Rate (RR) or Ventilatory Exhalation (VE) in Liters per Minute, outpaces the rise in Vo2. It is ROUGHLY analogous to Lactate Deflection Point #1, which is an invasive measurement that uses needles and blood to assess the processing of lactate as energy. When that value rises, exercise physiology changes energy use from mostly fat consumption – to fat and carbs consumption, to overwhelmingly carb use for energy. Lactate testing is invasive, adds risk, and the data collection is prone to error. As a result, I use Saturated Muscle Oxygen from a Moxy, and I also use DFAA-1, a measurement that looks at Heart Rate Variability, to assess these intensities, when I’m not wearing a Vo2Master.

Vo2master Gas Exchange FeO2 and EqO2
While I’m not discussing this chart in this blog, the information it’s providing is priceless. FeO2 is expired oxygen. If less o2 is exhaled, that means more is in the bloodstream and is helping the muscles with contraction. It shows the ‘Air’ in ‘Aerobic’ Exercise!

The Garmin Connect system, paired with Garmin bike computers and watches, uses power, heart rate, heart rate variability, respiratory rate from the chest strap, and weather information, to come up with heart rate and wattage zones. These values CHANGE with changes in volume and intensity over time, which is one more reason why I’m intrigued with what the Vo2Master has to say, in relation to the zones set by Garmin Connect.

Garmin Connect Algorithm Vs. Vo2Master Gas Exchange Results

Vo2master with Tidal Volume Ventilatory Exhalation and Respiratory Frequency
Here’s another Graph of the Vo2Master data plot. My Tidal Volume, at 3.7 liters, is actually a bit low; I need to train for deeper, slower breathing. This will delay the onset of VT1 and VT2, and thus improve my economy.

Here’s the comparison between the Vo2Master Zones, and the Garmin Zones after the test.

VT1/Zone 2 ‘Fat Burning’ Zone…

  • Vo2Master: 142 Beats Per Minute for VT1. Below that value, let’s call it ‘Zone 2’
  • Garmin Connect: 145 Beats Per Minute.
  • That’s a 2% difference.
  • VT1 Wattage Value? 183 watts
  • Zone 2 Upper Value for Garmin Connect: 179 watts.
  • That’s a 2% difference…

VT2/Functional Threshold Heart Rate and Power…

  • Vo2Master: 174 Beats per Minute. This is the ‘zone’ above which you’re on borrowed time, and below which, you can still exercise for an extended duration.
  • Garmin Connect? 172 Beats per Minute.
  • 1% delta. Again – I’ll take it.
  • Vo2Master Wattage at VT2/Threshold? 251 Watts.
  • Garmin Connect? 247 Watts.
  • A 1.5% delta. Again – for fitness purposes, I’ll take it.

Setting SmO2 Zones Based on Vo2Master Data

Once the VT1 and VT2 Values for wattage and traditional heart rate were set, I then took a look at the Saturated Muscle Oxygen information at those breakpoints.

Vo2master With SmO2 and ThB Values from a moxy monitor
I love, love, love my Moxy Monitors. They offer a noninvasive way to measure intensity on the ‘demand’ side, while heart rate provides information on the ‘supply’ side. Note the inclusion of Total Hemoglobin, or ThB. Thb declines until I reach VT1, then plateaus in my ‘tempo zone’, then begins to rise as I surpass Functional Threshold Power, or VT2.

Here’s what it showed:

  • SmO2 at VT1, where heart rate was 142 bpm and wattage was 183 watts, showed 37% saturation on my Left Lateralis. I usually use 40% saturation as my VT1/LT1/Zone2 breakpoint, so this value is in sync with my perception.
  • SmO2 at VT2, where heart rate was 174 and wattage was at 251 watts, was at 19% SmO2 Saturation. Again – I tend to use 20% saturation as the mark for my VT2/LT2/Threshold.
  • SmO2 measured by a Moxy on my Left Lateralis, showed highly correlated values with VT1 and VT2 for wattage and heart rate. That’s now three datapoints I can use when training, indoors and out, to correlate with the Gold Standard of Gas Exchange Analysis.

There are some great studies which show how SmO2 is equally valid to Lactate testing. The advantage is that SmO2 is noninvasive. I use SmO2 daily, and rely on it for optimal warmup and vasodilation, as well as for monitoring hydration and even looking at Moxy highs and lows during intervals, to gauge exhaustion more accurately. Most of you reading this already have a Garmin watch or bike computer and an advanced chest strap. Investing in a Moxy can augment your knowledge and improve upon your intuition about intensities and the duration you can ride at those levels.

Conclusion

Vo2Master GXT Zone Prescription
I usually simplify the 5 zones to just 3. Stay below 142 for base, stay above 174 for Vo2Max intensity, and work intervals above and below 251 and 183 watts (these will change with fitness).

The Vo2Master’s Vo2Max readings confirmed the calculations I am getting from Garmin Connect. Correlation between Vo2Master’s VT1 and VT2 for wattage, heart rate, and Saturated muscle oxygen, was also high.

The Vo2Master is the pinnacle of portable, accurate, physiological testing. I’ll be using it on some outdoor rides on the mountain bike to show just how hard mountain biking is, and how we can use that information to better train and prepare. Perhaps more importantly, at least in my case, the Vo2Max calculated through Garmin Connect, along with the thresholds and zones, means that I can train with higher confidence, knowing that the physiological data backs up Garmin’s claims and assumptions to a really high degree!

Thanks for reading, and #EnjoyTheRide!

SmO2 and Base

The Moxy’s SmO2 Sensor Helps Make Base Training Even More Effective

SmO2 and Base Richard Wharton Online Bike Coach Garmin Connect Image 1
Saturated Muscle Oxygen can make Base Training even more effective. Look for a rise in SmO2 at a known low intensity. Then, gently raise the intensity to find that SmO2 ‘sweet spot’ of aerobic training.

 
 

This week on my VQ Velocity Virtual Studio, we are focusing on a week of Periodization and Taper. We are not performing hard intervals, but instead, we are focusing on easier rides. I wear my Moxy for all my rides, but most of the time, I focus on Desaturation and Resaturation. This blog post is about SmO2 and Base training. We can use the Garmin Connect Ecosystem to highlight the PHYSIOLOGICAL BENEFITS of low-intensity rides.

SmO2 and Base Oxygen Saturation Levels

SmO2 and Base Richard Wharton Online Bike Coach Garmin Connect ThB Image 2
When you first start a ride, the body just isn’t ready for the strain. With proper warmup and vasodilation, SmO2 rises, ThB declines, and you’re achieving the benefits of ‘Base’!

SmO2 (Saturated Muscle Oxygen) readings show cyclists just how much Oxygen Supply is in the muscles. When a cyclist is riding for BASE, there should be plenty of oxygen available. As a ride progresses, the body warms up, and the blood vessels dilate. This offers the muscles more available oxygen. Think of SmO2 as ‘Volts’ in a car battery. When there’s a heavy draw on the engine (Demand), the volts may drop, like when the ignition is engaged. On electric vehicles, computers monitor watts (torque), volts, and Amps. I compare Amps with Total Hemoglobin, which I’ll discuss later in this post.

SmO2 and Base Richard Wharton Online Bike Coach Garmin Connect ThB Image 4
Patented Warmup. Create just a wee bit of strain, then recover, and watch your SmO2 and ThB values climb over 20-27 minutes (~200-300 Calories).

Since 2012, when I first started using SmO2 monitors from Moxy, I’ve discovered that SmO2 reveals great information about Base Training. When you first place a Moxy monitor on the left Lateralis, you usually get a reading of about 30-60% SmO2. I call this ‘Active Resting SmO2’. As you warm up, SmO2 will definitely drop a bit. If a cyclist or runner does NOT perform my trademarked Warmup Protocol, SmO2 dilation does NOT reach its’ full potential, and in my opinion, restricts some of the benefits of visualizing this feature. But IF the cyclist DOES perform my Warmup Protocol, then SmO2 can become a highly effective, visual method of visualizing just what Base provides.

Base Training Is an Energy-Positive Ride

Watch this 30-second advertisement for Del Monte Green Beans. Specifically, watch what happens when this young lady goes on a bike ride. This is EXACTLY what a ‘Base’ Ride should provide a cyclist or a runner. It should be ‘Energy Positive’ for mental wellness and spiritual fulfillment. It’s literally the way most of our bike rides should occur. The time you spend out there performing this may depend on goals, etc., but SmO2 can provide a window into exactly what is happening when a ride like this occurs.

SmO2 and Base Lead to Greater ‘Volts’ of Available Power, While Drawing Less ‘Amps’ (ThB) for the Same Amount of Physical Output

In this graph, you can see how my post-warmup Base ride begins with roughly 52% SmO2. While power output changes very little, vasodilation occurs, and available SmO2 rises at roughly the 45:00 mark, with a small dip in power output. The Smo2 continues to rise after that, until I perform a single 1-minute standing effort to change my saddle position.

***Standing Power is INCREDIBLY INEFFICIENT.

If you watch old videos of Alberto Contador, there are times before he had a serious crash, when he would climb seated, and honestly, he was a GC or stage threat. After his crash and long recovery, his body was never the same, and he climbed standing for even longer periods of time. It was very powerful, but very costly. 

However, after that single effort, SmO2 rose further, with little change in power.

Why Did SmO2 Start to Decline at the 1-hour mark?

mO2 and Base Richard Wharton Online Bike Coach Garmin Connect ThB Image 3
This is where I wish I had some coding knowledge. I would build a Garmin app that would run a 1-minute graph of SmO2 and ThB, along with recent Ceilings and Floors, so I could better visualize each parameter and make a more informed choice about intensity and nutrition or hydration.

Right around the 1:05 timeline, SmO2 began to decline. When we use Garmin Connect to zoom in, we can see that it began with a slight rise in power output. This was further exacerbated by another minute of standing and pedaling. SmO2 dropped further. Once I sat down, SmO2 Resaturated, but then continued its’ decline back to around 50%.

Why did this happen? Well, let’s look at the OTHER data point that we get when we ride with a Moxy; ThB.

What is ThB?

ThB stands for ‘Total Hemoglobin’, and it’s based on Millimols per Deciliter of volume. It’s the total count of red blood cells in your overall system. Hemoglobin is a protein that carries Oxygen to the Muscles. It’s another window into the ‘SUPPLY and DEMAND’ side of the SmO2 Equation. The more ThB we have, the more ‘AMPS’ we have available to help provide fresh oxygen to the muscles, to help keep SmO2 high.

Right around the 1:05 mark, when my SmO2 began to decline, Total Hemoglobin, which was declining from minute 33:00 to that point, began to rise. After the final standing moment, it rose further, and rose until I quit the ride at the 1:15 mark. So, SmO2 declines and ThB rises, for the same amount of power.

Now, this is CONJECTURE, because I AM NOT A SCIENTIST. But my own speculation is that I was getting short on blood sugar. I always ride these easier rides in a fasted state. It’s a way to train my body to burn more fat over time, as long as I don’t push too hard. But there are only between 800 and 1200 calories of carbohydrate in the circulatory system at any time, and in the 30 years that I’ve been cycling, my body tends to change at roughly 1200 calories, WITH CARB SUPPLEMENTATION. Without Carb supplementation, I think it’s very feasible to ‘see’ the body switching energy systems or becoming less efficient. At this point, I had burned roughly 800 calories, and had consumed nothing more than water (and probably not enough of that). Hence, ThB rose, SmO2 declined, while power and basic heart rate remained neutral.

Use Your Moxy SmO2 And Keep It HIGH!

SmO2 and Base Richard Wharton Online Bike Coach Garmin Connect ThB Image 5
For roughly the same amount of power, my body responded with less stress. Once I used up my blood sugar (I was in a fasted state), the body began looking elsewhere for energy, and my SmO2 and ThB both changed to become less efficient, while power stayed the same.

My personal SmO2 Floors and Ceilings are as such, but your own zones may vary.

  • My Max Recovery Saturation is at 80%. I rarely get there on an active bike ride, so 70% means my Muscles are being resupplied with fresh Oxygen and are ready for another effort.
  • My Active Base Saturation is between 40 and 70%. When I ride at those SmO2 intensities (remember, harder is lower, easier is higher), my body is using energy to make energy in my  mind, and these are fruitful, fun, functional rides.
  • An SmO2 below 20%, and usually below 17% puts me on ‘BORROWED TIME’, and is my Vo2Max range of intensity. It’s also unustainable for long periods.
  • An SmO2 between 20 and 25% is a great Threshold Intensity for me, regardless of the old-school heart rate and wattage values that have traditionally yielded these zones.

If you really want to get a window into your body, SmO2 (and ThB) provide real-time value to help you optimize your ride. Once you know your numbers, you can always try to track gains in power or loss in weight over time. You can also watch ThB to see if you’re perhaps in need of some carbs, or may even be approaching a bonk.

I’m going to continue to share my observations. If you own a Moxy, let me know if you see similar phenomena. I’d love to learn more.

Thanks for reading, and ENJOY THE RIDE!

Steve Neal’s Moxy Field

Coach Steve Neal’s Moxy Field Is INCREDIBLY EFFECTIVE!

Steve Neal Garmin Connect IQ Field
Steve Neal is one of the most experienced cycling and endurance coaches out there. He’s also a Moxy User, and knows how to get the most out of your investment.

Steve Neal is one of the most successful and qualified coaches that I know. He and I have followed a similar path. We both owned Cycling Studios. He and I have worked together to employ features in PerfPro Studio. He is a pioneer in Diaphragm breathing protocols. But most recently, he built a Garmin Connect Field that highlights EXACTLY what we need to know in regards to Saturated Muscle Oxygen!

Saturated Muscle Oxygen (SmO2) is a metric that uses NIRS (Near Infra-Red Spectroscospy) to measure Saturated Muscle Oxygen levels and Total Hemoglobin Counts (ThB). The product that Steve Neal and I both use, the Moxy Monitor, is a lab-accurate device. Here’s how Steve and I use it in workouts.

Steve Neal Uses Moxy Monitors to measure SmO2.
The Moxy is a noninvasive, durable NIRS sensor that is tuned to transmit SmO2 and ThB data to Garmin Head Units and Watches.

 

 

 

 

When a muscle contracts, it uses oxygen in the process. Moxy Monitors basically measure “Supply” (Smo2) based on “Demand”, which is measured in watts. It’s a merge of Physiology and Physics.  Muscles and Lungs (Oxygen) are augmented with the measurement of heart rate, all of which I have been studying for decades.  However, at certain levels of intensity, and depending on the muscle group being measured, the Moxy can help identify what I call “Floors”, or “Ceilings”. A “Floor” is an SmO2 intensity that can be sustained under duress. If intensity rises, the SmO2 will decline and can predict exhaustion. If SmO2 rises, we know the cyclist is riding at different levels of aerobic (sustainable) intensity.

STEVE NEAL’S MOXY FIELD ON GARMIN CONNECT IQ

Steve’s Moxy Field helps Moxy owners optimize the Physiological Impact of EACH and EVERY INTERVAL and RECOVERY. The concept is simple. The cyclist places their Moxy Monitor on a muscle group (I prefer the Left Lateralis). They then head over to the Garmin Connect IQ Field on their mobile phone or via Garmin Express, and download this Custom Field. In the Settings Tab, the cyclist will enter the specific Moxy ANT+ or BLE code for that unit. They also enter the location where the Moxy will be placed. I’ll talk about different locations and what they can tell us in a bit. Finally, the cyclist places the Custom IQ Field on their Garmin Ride Profile.

My profile screen looks like this:

Steve Neal Moxy Lap Field Garmin Connect IQ Field 4
The Steve Neal Moxy Lap Field is on the bottom of this screen. It eliminates the ThB Field, and replaces it with Instant Smo2 %. The number on the Right is the ‘Lap’ Average SmO2. It will change colors as the average rises and falls in the context of the lap, and the available Oxygen in the blooodstream.

The Steve Neal Moxy Field is used in conjunction with the ‘Lap’ Button. It eliminates the view of Total Hemoglobin, or ThB. The Field gives a lot of information in a small package.

You get:

Steve neal Moxy Lap Field Description
As important as the Instant SmO2 value is, it’s the COLOR and VALUE of the number on the RIGHT that is so critical. This is where having a BIG, HUGE, HEAD UNIT, like the Garmin 1040, comes in so handy. If Garmin still made their Head-Up Display, I swear, I’d ask them to include custom fields like this one in their options for fields.
  • Instant SmO2
  • Lap Average SmO2
    • and based on the color of the Lap Average SmO2, you can determine whether your SmO2 is RISING, FALLING, or is STABLE.
    • Red is Falling, Black is Stable, and Blue is Rising.

USE STEVE NEAL’S MOXY FIELD DURING A WORKOUT

Now, the results can be individualized, but the general trend for a workout might go like this:

First, have a look at this blog post and video that explains how I use the Moxy to determine proper warmup and preparation for a ride.
Moxy Monitor Warmup Protocol – Online Bike Coach

Then, look at the Steve Neal Moxy Field, and when an interval of, say, 3 minutes begins, hit the ‘lap’ button. As intensity increases, Smo2 will decrease, and the Lap Average SmO2 will also decrease. However, 3 minutes can be an eternity of effort. Intensity has to be modulated in order to complete the task. Using the Steve Neal Field, I can identify an Oxygen Demand which is SUSTAINABLE, and then I can watch the AVERAGE, trend down towards that value. If I’m near the end of the interval, and I feel like I have a little more to give, I can INCREASE INTENSITY, and DECREASE available Smo2, switch to an anaerobic energy system, and basically ‘Leave With Nothing Left’. Hit the lap button at the end of the interval, and you can watch the SmO2 value RISE to Maximum Resaturation, which is also a great time to replenish any carbs or rehydrate. Over the course of several intervals, it becomes easier to identify a ‘Floor’ of Smo2, below which you’re on seriously borrowed time. Steve Neal has several Diaphragm Breathing Protocols that affect Smo2 levels and can improve both Stamina and Strength for endurance and intensity days on the bike.

Looking at Moxy Results On Garmin Connect After A Ride

I recently performed a set of intervals on my Virtual Studio at app.vqvelocity.com, with a client who also had a Moxy Monitor. I am in California; he is in Massachusetts. We were both using Steve Neal’s Moxy field, and we both had the Moxy Monitor on our Left Lateralis. The interval set was 14 minutes long, with intensities at 120% of FTP for 22 seconds, and 8 seconds of recovery at 50% of FTP. But the WATTAGE GOALS FOR THE WORKOUT CHANGE WITH THE VALUES that show up on Steve Neal’s Moxy Field. This interval effort is what I call a ‘Push’. Let me explain.

VQ Velocity 22-8 intervals 2 sets
I created this interval set because the metabolic response to a stimulus is about 25 seconds. It also takes about 8 seconds to reset the ATP in your legs when recovering. The 22-8’s have some intensity and recovery overlap, but they yield a VERY high overall normalized and actual average when properly employed. They’re actually a “Threshold” workout…

The overwhelming research on cycling reveals that the sport is overwhelmingly aerobic in its’ demands. Sure, we love to talk about intensities and intervals for brief moments here and there, but when the ride is over and uploaded, it’s our AEROBIC economy that makes such a difference. The goal of training, therefore, is four-fold; we want to improve STAMINA, STRENGTH, SPEED, and SKILL. Aerobic Power and economy is akin to Stamina, and that’s what we were focused on in this effort. But you can ‘see’ whether you’re aerobic or not, via the Steve Neal Moxy Field. A cyclist can also see when they’ve tripped over that line of Threshold, and they’re dipping into their own, personal, time-limited, “Well of Despair”! The second-by-second watts are less important here. What IS important is getting the cyclist to their own, personal, average SmO2, that is both painful, but yet also sustainable. This workout was a Threshold Workout, and the Moxy data shows just that. Aerobics is the ‘Push’ of Economy and Stamina. Anaerobic Intensities and Vo2Max efforts, are the ‘Pull’.

Garmin Connect Moxy Quad Watts Heart Rate
This is a screen report from the Garmin Connect File. Steve’s Moxy Field showed me a cumulative average and an idea of intensity that I just can’t get from traditional heart rate. If you look at the grey data points, which is SmO2, you’ll see that around minute 40, SmO2 began to rise. Why? Look at the RECOVERY WATTS in purple. I began to take those 8 second recoveries more seriously, and my Saturated Muscle Oxygen rose in accordance. ‘ON’ Power stayed high, and this allowed me to do MORE of the ‘Work’, which is beneficial.

On my first interval, I hit the ‘Lap’ button on my Garmin 1040 Solar, and rode at the varying intensities that the workout prescribed, until I hit a value of Saturation below 20%. The stochastic nature of the intervals within the set show perpetual swings of wattage, but the SmO2 drifted between 14 and 18%. For the First Interval Set, I averaged 17% for SmO2. Average power? 292 watts. This is WELL ABOVE the predicted Thresholds that have been set for me by numerous other Threshold Calculators. The second Interval? 20% SmO2 with power at a more modest 261 Watts, still above my ‘Calculated” Threshold. Traditional Heart Rates? They were 172 bpm and 168 bpm, both arguably UNDER my claimed Threshold of 173 bpm.

Steve Neal Moxy Field With SmO2 Wattage and DFAA-1
Here’s the second set. I wanted to show the SmO2 values with DFAA-1 values from AlphaHRV, which is another great Field found in Connect IQ. I use both fields, but I find that Moxy ‘Floors’ are more acute than the ‘rolling 2-minute’ value that we commonly use to calculate DFAA-1. 

Moxy Values are more accurate and precise than traditional Heart Rate and Wattage Claims for Threshold Values. They also highlight FATIGUE and arguably, DEHYDRATION or a BONK. That’s another discussion for another day, but the gist of it is this; We’ve had this tool for about 10 years now, but it required mental calculation to determine Aerobic and Anaerobic Thresholds. Now, with the Steve Neal Moxy Field, we get Instant values, Average Values, and a Trend, which is worth its’ weight in gold.

CONCLUSION

Everyone knows how much I love power meters. More recently, I’ve fallen in love with the study of Heart Rate Variability. I love how that works with our bodies in a more holistic way. With the release of Steve’s Moxy Field, we now have the tool to observe thresholds acutely, and then determine ways to dive through them, stay at or just above them, and recover from efforts more effectively.

I’ll save the next blog post for another aspect of Steve Neal’s Moxy Field, where we will look at the same workout, but from the aspect of the LEFT DELTOID. The numbers are going to be more nuanced, but they continue to reveal some INCREDIBLE, REPEATABLE, NONINVASIVE information.

Until then, ENJOY THE RIDE!

 

Base Ride Number 2 – Pre-Brief

Ya Gotta SLEEP in order to PERFORM!

Apparently, the winner of this year’s Tour de France, who also won the race LAST YEAR, has a secret. He knows how to SLEEP and RECOVER.

I obviously do not.

I’ve tried everything; blackout curtains, weighted blankets, cold room, no caffeine past 10am, less than two beers a night, no overstimulation for too long…. Nothing really works. I’ve been tracking my Testosterone levels for at least 7 years, to see if that warrants intervention, but honestly, that’s an expensive and invasive step that I’m not willing to take at this time.

But I don’t sleep. And when I don’t sleep, weight management and cycling performance are challenged.

Here’s today’s Pre-Brief that describes the overview of my sleep, my weight gain, and my PREDICTED (not actual), Vo2max via Garmin Connect.